Most handheld pitters work the same way. An olive sits in a small cup, and a rod punches the pit out through a hole beneath it. Some models close like tongs with a spring in the handles, which suits one-handed work; cherry and olive pitters with a plunger press straight down instead. Either style follows the same rhythm.
How-to
How to Use an Olive Pitter
How to use an olive pitter in five steps, what changes for firm green olives, and how to pit olives with a knife when no pitter is on hand.
An olive pitter does one job: it pushes the pit straight out through the tip and leaves the olive whole, which a knife rarely manages. The tool is simple, but a few habits decide whether each olive comes out clean or mangled, and firm green olives behave differently from soft black ones.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
Five steps to pit olives with a handheld pitter
- Set a small bowl nearby for pits if the pitter has no built-in compartment to catch them.
- Seat one olive in the cup so the pit lines up with the rod and the hole.
- Squeeze the handles, or press the plunger, in one firm, steady motion.
- If the pit does not clear, repeat the squeeze until it drops out through the hole.
- Release the handles, lift the pitted olive out and check that no fragment of pit is left inside.
Why firm green olives need more force
Pit placement is the same for every olive, but the fruit is not. In firm green olives the flesh clings to the pit, so the squeeze usually needs more effort and sometimes a second pass. Soft black olives let go almost at once. If a pitter feels stuck on a green olive, a second firm squeeze is the usual fix; a harder grip on an olive that is wedged crooked in the cup only tears the flesh.
Pitters sold for cherries are often sold for olives too, and a model such as the OXO Good Grips Cherry & Olive Pitter lists many varieties of olives among the fruit it handles. For hand tools that grip the olive in a cup and push the pit out, the best olive pitter page compares the options.
How to pit an olive without a pitter
A chef's knife does the job when no pitter is around. Lay the olive on a cutting board, press the flat of the blade onto it until the flesh splits, then pull the pit out with your fingers. Black olives are softer and give way easily; green olives are firmer and need more pressure. Either way the pressure should be firm but gentle, because a hard press can crack the pit and leave sharp fragments in the flesh.
Keep the cutting edge angled away from you while pressing. The olive ends up split or crushed, which suits chopped olives for salads, tapenade or drinks, but not whole ones.
When the pitter is worth reaching for
The pitter earns its place when olives must stay whole, such as for stuffing or a platter at a gathering, since the pit leaves through a small hole in the tip. For a handful of olives going into a sauce or salad, the flat of a knife is quicker than fetching a gadget.