Kitchen & Dining · Bakeware
Best Pan for Baking Biscuits
Weigh bare aluminum against nonstick steel, shallow sides against deep ones, and dark finishes against light to find the right biscuit pan.
Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
At a glance
1
Best for Small BatchesGoodCook
3
Best for Easy HandlingNutriChef
4
Everyday Cookie Sheet SetGoodCook
5
Best for Savory BakesFarberware
6
Most Size OptionsGoodCook
7
Best Uncoated PickDoughmakers
Detailed reviews
This is the smallest footprint in the lineup, and that suits the baker who turns out a modest batch of biscuits rather than a full tray. It is billed for biscuits alongside brownies and cornbread, and its 7 x 11 inch size also makes it a handy fit for smaller casseroles and protein bars.
The steel body carries a scratch-resistant nonstick coating that is metal spatula safe, so lifting biscuits out with a spatula is not a concern. Owners report that it cooks evenly and cleans up without a fight. We'd hand wash it, as the maker advises, because durability is where this pan draws its sharpest complaints: owners mention rust and a peeling finish after a short stretch of use. Fit in a toaster oven is also inconsistent, so measure your oven before counting on it there.
Pros
- Cooks evenly in a compact size
- Easy cleanup after baking
- Releases baked goods without sticking
Cons
- Rust and peeling reported after short use
- Toaster oven fit is inconsistent
Key features (4)
- Heavy-duty steel body built to resist warping over time
- Scratch-resistant nonstick coating that tolerates metal spatulas when serving
- Compact 7 x 11 inch rectangular footprint for small batches
- Limited lifetime warranty from the manufacturer on this pan
Of the pans here, this two-pack is the one most clearly aimed at biscuits, since the name itself pairs them with brownies. Each pan measures 11 x 7 x 1.5 inches, so you can bake two batches at once or keep one pan for sweet bakes and one for savory. Handles make moving a loaded pan in and out of the oven easier, and the heavy-gauge steel is meant to brown food evenly.
Owners report that the pans cook evenly, release food cleanly (even baked-on cheese lets go), wash up easily and suit everything from buttermilk biscuits to cornbread and brownies. Durability feedback leans positive too, including notes on rust resistance and a heavy feel. Set beside the GoodCook Brownie Pan 7x11 Inch, where rust is the recurring complaint, the Wilton pans draw far steadier praise for lasting. They are dishwasher safe, though gentle hand washing gives the best results.
Pros
- Two pans for double batches
- Sturdy build owners expect to last
- Releases even baked-on cheese easily
- Cooks biscuits and brownies evenly
Cons
- Hand washing gives best results
Key features (4)
- Two 11 x 7 x 1.5 inch pans in one pack
- Heavy-gauge steel body for even heating and browning
- Scratch-resistant non-stick coating for easy release and quick cleanup
- Convenient handles built for moving pans in and out of the oven
This set is built around handling. Red silicone handles give a firm grip when you pull a hot sheet from the oven, and the three pans (small, medium and large) stack to save cabinet space. They are oven safe to 446 degrees Fahrenheit and have a PTFE, PFOA and PFOS-free nonstick coating on carbon steel, and owners report that they clean easily and look good on the counter.
The weak spot is longevity. A common complaint is warping under high heat, and owners also describe a coating that peels in the wash, scratches easily and can rust. Some find the sheets smaller than they expected, and the harshest feedback calls the overall quality poor. These are flat cookie sheets, so biscuits get the open airflow they like, but bakers who want a steadier tray will find the Doughmakers Biscuit Sheet Commercial Grade Aluminum more reassuring, since owners say it doesn't warp.
Pros
- Silicone handles give a confident grip
- Three sizes stack for storage
- Easy to clean after baking
Cons
- Warping reported at high heat
- Non-stick coating can peel
- Rust and scratching reported
Key features (4)
- Carbon steel pans in small, medium and large sizes
- Heat-resistant lacquer exterior with an oven rating of 446 degrees Fahrenheit
- Stackable wide tray design that saves cabinet storage space
- PTFE, PFOA and PFOS-free nonstick coating on carbon steel
Three 13 x 9 inch carbon steel sheets make this a practical set for batches of biscuits, cookies and sheet pan dinners. Owners report that food slides off easily, that cookies and other bakes cook evenly, and that the sheets wash up without trouble. The maker pairs a scratch-resistant nonstick coating with heavy-duty gauge steel meant to spread heat evenly.
The drawbacks are real, though. Owners report significant warping in the oven, rust on some sheets and coating that wears off over time. Sizing also surprises some buyers: the 13 inch figure refers to the inside dimension, so the trays run smaller than the number suggests. Its sibling, the GoodCook Nonstick Baking Sheet Set 3 Pack, uses the same coating formula, so the choice mostly comes down to whether you want a range of sheet sizes.
Pros
- Cookies and baked items slide off
- Cooks food evenly
- Easy to clean
Cons
- Warping reported in the oven
- Rust and coating wear reported
- Sizing runs smaller than expected
Key features (4)
- Three 13 x 9 inch carbon steel baking sheets
- Scratch-resistant nonstick coating with an exclusive manufacturer formula
- Heavy-duty gauge steel meant to spread heat evenly across the sheet
- Dishwasher safe, though hand washing extends coating life
We think of this pan as the savory-leaning pick. The 9 x 13 inch rectangle gives a full batch of biscuits room to sit, and it doubles for casseroles, lasagna and brownies. It is oven safe to 450 degrees Fahrenheit, made without PFAS, PFOA, lead or cadmium, and built heavy enough to resist warping and hot spots.
Owners report solid nonstick performance, easy cleanup and a sturdy feel, with brownies, bars and rolls all turning out well. Color matters here: owners who also bake in dark gray pans such as the GoodCook Everyday Baking Sheet Set Nonstick say the lighter Farberware finish tracks recipe times more closely, which helps keep biscuit bottoms from browning too fast. Hand washing is recommended for best performance, even though the pan is dishwasher safe.
Pros
- Sturdy, solid-feeling construction
- Food releases without sticking
- Lighter finish bakes close to recipe times
Cons
- Hand washing recommended for best performance
Key features (4)
- 9 x 13 inch rectangular pan without a lid
- Oven safe to 450 degrees Fahrenheit for baking and roasting
- Heavy-duty construction designed to resist warping and hot spots
- Nonstick coating made without PFAS, PFOA, lead or cadmium
The extra sizes are the difference from the GoodCook Everyday Baking Sheet Set Nonstick, which sticks to three 13 x 9 inch trays. Here the set runs from a 13 x 9 inch small to a 15 x 10 inch medium and a 17 x 11 inch large, so you can match the sheet to the batch, and owners say the different sizes help keep mess out of the oven.
Owners report easy cleaning, a nonstick surface where food releases without a fight, and a sturdy, thick feel. The complaints are about durability: rust and staining show up readily, and a common complaint is warping when the sheets heat up. One owner found a rust puddle after air drying, so dry them with a towel right after hand washing. The largest sheet can also be too big for a smaller oven, so check your interior before buying. A limited lifetime warranty backs the set.
Pros
- Three sizes suit different batches
- Food doesn't stick; easy cleanup
- Sturdy, thick feel owners like
Cons
- Rust and staining reported
- Warping reported when heated
- Largest sheet may not fit some ovens
Key features (4)
- Three carbon steel sheets sized 13 x 9, 15 x 10 and 17 x 11 inches
- Limited lifetime warranty from the manufacturer on the full set
- Heavy-duty gauge steel built for even heat distribution across sheets
- Scratch-resistant nonstick coating with an exclusive manufacturer formula
Peeling and rusting coatings are the recurring complaint with the NutriChef Nonstick Cookie Sheets 3 Piece, and bare aluminum sidesteps the coating question entirely. This sheet is 18 gauge aluminum measuring 10 x 14 inches with a half-inch rim, which keeps the sides shallow so air moves freely around biscuits. Its patented pebble pattern lifts baked goods slightly off the metal, which promotes even browning and quick release.
Owners report that cookies slide off, that scones, cinnamon rolls and even battered fish fillets bake evenly, and that the sheet cleans up easily, copes with toaster ovens and camp stoves, and doesn't warp. Scratches from metal utensils don't hurt performance, since there is no coating to damage. The mixed note is cosmetic: the metal discolors over time. Hand wash promptly and it is heat safe to 428 degrees Fahrenheit. Long loaves are a job for the french bread pan, so keep this sheet for rounds and drop biscuits.
Pros
- Bare aluminum with airflow-friendly pebble pattern
- Owners say it doesn't warp
- Works in toaster ovens and camp stoves
- Metal utensils won't hurt performance
Cons
- Metal discolors with use over time
- Hand wash promptly after baking
Key features (4)
- 18 gauge aluminum construction in a 10 x 14 inch size
- Patented pebble pattern that lifts biscuits off the metal
- Heat safe to 428 degrees Fahrenheit, with strengthened handle areas
- Shallow half-inch rim that keeps air moving around biscuits
Side by side
| Pick | Size | Warranty |
|---|
#1 Best for Small Batches GoodCook | 7 x 11 inches | Limited Lifetime |
#2 Best Overall Wilton | — | — |
#3 Best for Easy Handling NutriChef | — | 1 YEAR |
#4 Everyday Cookie Sheet Set GoodCook | 13" x 9" | — |
#5 Best for Savory Bakes Farberware | 9" x 13" | — |
#6 Most Size Options GoodCook | — | Limited Lifetime |
#7 Best Uncoated Pick Doughmakers | 10" x 14" | — |
How to Choose a Pan for Baking Biscuits
Which material bakes the best biscuits?
Heat conduction decides how evenly the bottoms brown. Aluminum moves heat quickly and evenly, steel is sturdy and tolerates hot ovens, and cast iron holds heat for a long time but needs seasoning. In this lineup the Doughmakers Biscuit Sheet Commercial Grade Aluminum is the only bare aluminum pan, and the rest are nonstick steel.
- Aluminum: quick, even heat and reliable browning
- Carbon steel with nonstick: easy release, so check for warping
- Cast iron: strong heat retention, but it needs seasoning
- Stainless steel: durable and rust-resistant
Do pan size and depth change the result?
Yes, and mostly through airflow. Shallow sides let heat circulate around each biscuit, so flat sheets and low rims favor crisper sides and tops, while deeper rectangular pans hold biscuits closer together. Depth is also where biscuits part ways with savory baking; the best pan for baking fish asks for sides that hold juices in, while biscuits want shallow sides.
Size decides how many fit at once, so measure your oven before buying. The GoodCook Nonstick Baking Sheet Set 3 Pack lets you match the sheet to the batch, though its largest tray can overshoot a smaller oven.
Should the pan be light or dark?
Dark pans absorb heat faster, which can burn biscuit bottoms before the tops finish. If you bake in a dark finish, lower the oven temperature a little or check early. A lighter pan generally follows recipe times more closely, which is why we'd point bakers who want predictable timing to the Farberware Nonstick Cake Pan 9 x 13 Inch.
How do you keep biscuits from sticking and the pan from rusting?
Preparation and drying matter as much as the pan itself. Coated pans release easily at first, but coatings wear, and uncoated metal relies on a little fat or parchment. These steps cover both.
- Preheat the oven fully before the biscuits go in.
- Grease the pan lightly, or line it with parchment paper.
- Space the biscuits apart so heat circulates around each one.
- Lower the temperature or shorten the time in dark pans.
- Let the pan cool before washing it.
- Wash by hand with a soft sponge and warm, soapy water.
- Dry every edge with a towel right away to prevent rust.
Our picks at a glance
1
Best for Small BatchesGoodCook
3
Best for Easy HandlingNutriChef
4
Everyday Cookie Sheet SetGoodCook
5
Best for Savory BakesFarberware
6
Most Size OptionsGoodCook
7
Best Uncoated PickDoughmakers
Frequently asked
Do biscuits need a nonstick pan?
No. Biscuits release well from a lightly greased or parchment-lined pan of bare metal, and an uncoated aluminum sheet avoids the peeling coatings some owners report on nonstick sets. If you prefer coated, the Wilton Biscuit and Brownie Pan 2 Pack is the pick that pairs a nonstick surface with a biscuit-ready size.
Can I bake biscuits on a regular cookie sheet?
Yes, a flat sheet gives biscuits plenty of airflow. The catch is thin metal, which can bow in a hot oven, so heavier gauge matters. Among the sheets here, the Doughmakers Biscuit Sheet Commercial Grade Aluminum is the one owners say stays flat.
Is it safe to use a metal spatula on the pan?
It depends on the surface. The GoodCook Brownie Pan 7x11 Inch carries a coating described as metal spatula safe, but bare aluminum settles the question most simply, because there is no coating to scratch.