Comparison

Sifter vs Strainer

Sifter vs strainer: a sifter aerates dry ingredients and breaks up lumps, a strainer separates solids from liquids. See how they differ and when to use each.

A sifter and a strainer both have a mesh and a handle, so they get swapped constantly, yet they are built for opposite jobs. One sorts dry powder and the other separates solids from liquid, and using the wrong one means lumpy batter or a clogged screen.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

One tool is for powders, the other for liquids

What sifters do is loosen and aerate dry ingredients: flour, cocoa and powdered sugar pass through the mesh and come out free of lumps. A strainer works the other way around, holding solids back while liquid passes through, which is why it turns up in soup, sauce, stock and juice work.

The words overlap in everyday use and many cooks call both of them sieves, so the task in the recipe is the real clue.

The two tools compared by attribute

Mechanism, mesh and daily jobs are where the two tools part ways.

AttributeSifterStrainer
Main jobAerates and breaks up lumpsSeparates solids from liquids
Works onDry ingredientsLiquids and wet foods
MechanismCrank, squeeze or spring handleHandheld, no moving parts
Typical tasksFlour, cocoa, powdered sugarStocks, sauces, rinsing rice
MeshFine, built for powdersCoarse to fine, by type

For baking, a sifter is the better pick

A sifter aerates flour and mixes dry ingredients evenly, and a handheld crank or spring sifter is a favorite of keen bakers for very tender cakes. For a routine recipe that calls for sifting, any sieve will do, though clump-prone ingredients like cocoa and cake flour deserve the step every time.

The best sifter for powdered sugar compares crank, spring and shaker styles.

What a strainer handles better

Anything wet goes to the strainer. A fine mesh one skims foam from stock and purées fruit, while a sifter used on wet ingredients tends to clog.

Frequently asked

What can you use to sift powdered sugar without a sifter?

A fine mesh strainer works well: add the sugar, then tap the side or press it through with a spoon over the bowl. It aerates a little less than a crank sifter, which matters mainly for very delicate cakes.

Can you use a sifter for liquids?

It is not recommended. Liquids and wet ingredients tend to clog the fine mesh, so a strainer is the better tool for anything that is not dry.