Kitchen & Dining · Cookware

Best Pan to Cook Steak on the Stove

Cast iron or nonstick, ridged or flat: how material, weight and size change a steak's crust and your cleanup, with seven stovetop pans compared.

Affiliate disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

At a glance

3
Utopia Kitchen Cast Iron Skillet 12 Inch Pre-Seasoned PFAS-Free Black
Best Big Cast Iron Skillet
Utopia Kitchen

Utopia Kitchen 12 Inch Cast Iron Skillet

Detailed reviews

SENSARTE Nonstick Grill Pan for Stove Tops, Versatile Griddle with Pour Spouts, Square Big Cooking Surface, Durable Skillet Indoor & Outdoor Grilling. PFOA Free, 9.5 Inch
#1 PickBest Overall
Sensarte

Sensarte Nonstick Grill Pan 9.5 Inch

A light, ridged nonstick pan that sears steak with grill marks and cleans up with a wipe.

Ideal for: Cooks who want grill marks and quick cleanup on any type of stove, and would rather skip seasoning and a heavy pan.

We'd point most home cooks toward this one first. Its die-cast aluminum body, ridged surface and nonstick coating give you grill marks without the upkeep that cast iron asks for, and the pour spouts on both sides make draining rendered fat easy. It is rated for gas, electric, induction and glass or ceramic cooktops, so it suits nearly any stove.

Owners report that food releases cleanly, that heat arrives quickly and evenly, and that bacon, steaks and burgers all cook well. The handle attaches with a single screw and stays cool. For darker char marks, expect to run the burner hotter than you might with other pans.

The 9.5 inch size is the smallest of our picks, which suits one or two steaks and a compact burner. At 2 pounds it is also the lightest, which matters if you lift a pan often.

Pros

  • Lightest pick in the lineup
  • Nonstick surface cleans with a wipe
  • Pour spouts drain fat easily
  • Works on induction and other cooktops

Cons

  • Needs higher heat for darker char
  • Smallest cooking surface of these picks
Key features (4)
  • Die-cast aluminum body with raised ribs for grill marks
  • Nonstick coating free of PFOA and PFOS
  • Bakelite handle designed to stay cool in use
  • Compatible with gas, electric, induction and ceramic cooktops
Lodge Square Cast Iron Grill Pan, PFAS-Free, 10.5 Inches
#2 PickBest Cast Iron Grill Pan
Lodge

Lodge Square Cast Iron Grill Pan 10.5 Inches

A heavy square cast iron grill pan built for a deep, steakhouse-style sear.

Ideal for: Steak lovers comfortable with cast iron care who want deep ridges, a high-heat sear, and a pan that goes from stove to oven.

This is the pick for people who want real cast iron searing and ridges that keep steak out of its own grease. It is made from iron and oil, with no nonstick chemistry, and it works on stovetops, in ovens, on grills and over a campfire. Owners report that steaks and burgers come out great and that heat spreads evenly across the grid.

Next to the Sensarte Nonstick Grill Pan 9.5 Inch, this pan gives up lightness for heat holding: it weighs 6.5 pounds against that pan's 2 pounds, and you will feel that at the sink as well. A common complaint is difficulty cleaning the grid after cooking, and owners also report rust and a coating that peels, so dry it right away and keep it oiled. Owners report that the heft feels reassuring; a common complaint is that it is quite heavy.

The lifetime limited warranty from Lodge adds some reassurance for a pan many buyers keep for good.

Pros

  • Holds heat for strong steak searing
  • Ridges channel fat away from meat
  • Safe on stove, oven, grill and campfire
  • Backed by a lifetime limited warranty

Cons

  • Reported rust and peeling coating
  • Grid can be hard to clean
  • Heavy to lift and handle
Key features (4)
  • Square cast iron cooking surface with raised grill ridges
  • Seasoned finish made only from iron and oil
  • Works on stovetops, ovens, grills and campfires
  • Free of PFOA, PTFE and PFAS
Utopia Kitchen Cast Iron Skillet 12 Inch Pre-Seasoned PFAS-Free Black
#3 PickBest Big Cast Iron Skillet
Utopia Kitchen

Utopia Kitchen 12 Inch Cast Iron Skillet

A roomy 12 inch cast iron skillet for flat-surface searing and family-size meals.

Ideal for: Households that cook larger steaks or several pieces at once and don't mind seasoning upkeep on a big, heavy pan.

If you would rather get a full-contact crust than grill lines, a flat skillet does that, and this one is the largest pan here. Owners report that it sears steaks well, cooks evenly, and handles frying chicken and baking as readily as steak. It arrives pre-seasoned and works on the stove, on a grill and at the campsite.

Choose this over the Lodge Square Cast Iron Grill Pan 10.5 Inches when you cook for more than one or two and want space for sides in the same pan. It also weighs more, at 7.58 pounds, though owners report that it feels lighter than typical cast iron, and a common complaint is that it is very heavy anyway.

Feedback on the finish is uneven. Owners report that the pre-seasoning can arrive properly done; a common complaint is that it needs extra work, that food sticks, and that rust appears early. A thorough dry and a coat of oil after each wash is the sensible habit with this one.

Pros

  • Largest cooking surface in the lineup
  • Sears steaks and fries chicken evenly
  • Pre-seasoned and ready for the stove
  • Handles oven, grill and camp cooking

Cons

  • Rust reported early in use
  • Pre-seasoning quality is inconsistent
  • Food sticking reported; release varies
Key features (4)
  • Twelve inch cast iron skillet with strong heat retention
  • Pre-seasoned with vegetable oil for immediate use
  • Suited to stovetop, grill and camping cooking
  • Large surface for family portions and sides
CAROTE 11 Inch Nonstick Grill Pan for Steak, Premium Granite Coating
#4 PickBest Roomy Nonstick
Carote

Carote Nonstick Grill Pan 11 Inch

An 11 inch granite-coated grill pan with a cool handle and easy cleanup.

Ideal for: Anyone who wants nonstick convenience with enough room for a steak and sides, and who cooks on induction or other modern stoves.

We like this pan for cooks who want the convenience of nonstick but need more room than a 9.5 inch pan allows. Its thick base, granite-style coating and ridges are aimed at even heat and visible grill marks, and it runs on gas, induction, electric and ceramic cooktops. Owners report that food does not stick, that it heats evenly, that the handle stays cool, and that it stays steady on the burner.

The Sensarte Nonstick Grill Pan 9.5 Inch is the smaller, lighter sibling, at 2 pounds against this pan's 3.09 pounds, so this one is the better fit when you want two steaks, or a steak and vegetables, to share the surface. Owners describe cooking steak and asparagus together, and several grilled cheese sandwiches at once.

The handle goes on with one screw. Owners report that the color can differ from the product photos, a cosmetic issue rather than a cooking one.

Pros

  • Roomier surface than the smaller nonstick pick
  • Non-stick, easy to rinse clean
  • Handle stays cool during cooking
  • Works on gas, induction and ceramic

Cons

  • Color can differ from product photos
Key features (4)
  • Granite-style nonstick coating that works with minimal oil
  • Thick base for even heat across the surface
  • Wood-grain handle that resists warping and stays comfortable
  • Compatible with gas, induction, electric and ceramic cooktops
Lodge Pre-Seasoned Cast Iron Skillet, PFAS-Free, 10.25 Inches
#5 PickBest Classic Skillet
Lodge

Lodge 10.25 Inch Cast Iron Skillet

The familiar pre-seasoned Lodge skillet, a flat-pan way to build a steak crust.

Ideal for: Cooks who want one dependable cast iron skillet for searing, burgers and baking, and are happy to season and dry it by hand.

This is the straightforward flat-surface option: a 10.25 inch cast iron skillet that comes pre-seasoned, works on the stove and in the oven, and is made in the USA by Lodge. Owners report that it is a great size for burgers, baking and searing steaks, and that it comes ready to cook.

At 5.07 pounds it is lighter than the Utopia Kitchen 12 Inch Cast Iron Skillet at 7.58 pounds, and its smaller diameter suits a pair of steaks better than a crowd. It is still cast iron; owners report that the heft is satisfying, while a common complaint is that it is too heavy.

Owners also report rust after the first use, and a common complaint is food sticking even with oil, so keep a seasoning routine in mind. The lifetime warranty is a plus for a pan meant to last years.

Pros

  • Comes pre-seasoned and ready to use
  • Made in the USA by Lodge
  • Oven safe for finishing thick cuts
  • Lifetime warranty from Lodge

Cons

  • Rust reported after first use
  • Heavy for everyday handling
Key features (4)
  • Pre-seasoned cast iron skillet with a teardrop handle
  • Strong heat retention for searing and frying
  • Oven safe and compatible with the stovetop
  • Suited to camping and everyday cooking alike
Lodge Reversible Cast Iron Grill/Griddle Pan, 16.75 x 9.5 Inches
#6 PickMost Versatile
Lodge

Lodge Reversible Cast Iron Grill/Griddle Pan

A two-burner reversible plate, grill ridges on one side and a flat griddle on the other.

Ideal for: Cooks with a two-burner stove or outdoor grill who want one reversible plate for steaks, pancakes, eggs and bacon.

No other pick here covers as many jobs. One side is a ridged grill for steaks, the other a flat griddle for pancakes, eggs and bacon, and it spans two burners, which makes it a breakfast-for-a-crowd tool as much as a steak pan. It is pre-seasoned, PFAS-free, works on induction and any other cooktop, and can go over a campfire. Owners report that it sears steaks well, cooks pancakes and bacon, and feels built to last.

It is the heaviest option, at 9.38 pounds, and much bulkier than the Lodge 10.25 Inch Cast Iron Skillet, so storage and handling are real considerations. A common complaint is that the area between two burners runs cooler than the ends, that it can rock on certain burner grates, and that food sticks in places.

If you want one plate for dinner, breakfast and outdoor cooking, this is the one. If you only want a steak pan, a single round pan is simpler.

Pros

  • Reversible grill and griddle sides
  • Spans two burners for bigger batches
  • Works on induction and over campfires
  • Pre-seasoned and PFAS-free

Cons

  • Middle can run cooler between burners
  • Heavy and bulky to store
  • Can rock on certain burner grates
Key features (4)
  • Reversible cast iron plate with grill and griddle sides
  • Double-burner configuration for larger breakfast and dinner spreads
  • Induction compatible, oven safe and campfire friendly
  • Pre-seasoned, PFAS-free and non-toxic cast iron
Jean-Patrique The Whatever Griddle Pan for Stove Top with Lid, 10.6 inch – Aluminum Indoor Grill Pan - Lightweight and Nonstick
#7 PickBest Lightweight Pick
Jean-Patrique

Jean-Patrique Whatever Griddle Pan 10.6 Inch

A cast aluminum grill pan with deep sides that moves from stove to oven.

Ideal for: Cooks who want a lighter pan for steak, fish and chops, and who will wear an oven mitt on the handles.

For cooks who find cast iron too much to lift, this pan is the lighter answer. It is cast aluminum with a nonstick finish and deep sides that keep splatter in, and it works on induction and other cooktops, plus in the oven. Owners report that it grills steaks, salmon and pork chops evenly, that it wipes clean, and that it flavors food with a good grilled taste.

It weighs 3.09 pounds, the same as the Carote Nonstick Grill Pan 11 Inch, and far less than the Lodge Reversible Cast Iron Grill/Griddle Pan at 9.38 pounds, so it is easy to shift around a kitchen. A lid comes with it, which helps with splatter or keeping a finished steak warm.

The main caution is the handles. Owners report that they get very hot during use and are not heat resistant, so oven mitts or silicone grips are essential.

Pros

  • Much lighter than cast iron
  • Deep sides help limit splatter
  • Usable on stove and in oven
  • Wipes clean with a paper towel

Cons

  • Handles get very hot in use
Key features (4)
  • Cast aluminum body with nonstick finish and ridged base
  • Deep ridges and sides to contain splatter
  • Works on stovetop, oven and induction cooking
  • Lid included with the pan

Side by side

PickItem weightItem dimensions
#1 Best Overall
Sensarte
2 pounds17 × 10 × 2 inches
#2 Best Cast Iron Grill Pan
Lodge
6.5 pounds17.25 × 10.5 × 2.62 inches
#3 Best Big Cast Iron Skillet
Utopia Kitchen
7.58 pounds17 × 12 × 2.2 inches
#4 Best Roomy Nonstick
Carote
3.09 pounds10 × 11 × 2 inches
#5 Best Classic Skillet
Lodge
5.07 pounds16.12 × 10 × 2 inches
#6 Most Versatile
Lodge
9.38 pounds9.5 × 0.5 × 16.75 inches
#7 Best Lightweight Pick
Jean-Patrique
3.09 pounds13.39 × 10.63 × 1.77 inches

How to Choose a Pan for Steak on the Stove

Which material sears steak best?

Material decides how well a pan holds heat, and heat is what browns a steak. Cast iron stores a lot of it and recovers well when cold meat hits the surface, which is why it sits at the center of most steak advice. The cost is weight and seasoning care. For the grill-ridge version, the Lodge Square Cast Iron Grill Pan 10.5 Inches is our cast iron pick; for a flat surface, the Utopia Kitchen 12 Inch Cast Iron Skillet offers the most room.

Nonstick aluminum trades some of that heat storage for lightness and easy cleaning, and the Sensarte Nonstick Grill Pan 9.5 Inch is the one we'd start with there. Stainless steel and carbon steel are also well regarded for steak, though none of the picks above use them.

How big and how heavy should the pan be?

Crowding is the common mistake: too much meat in too small a pan lowers the temperature, so steak steams instead of browning. A pan that fits one or two steaks with room around them is the practical target. Our picks run from 9.5 inch to 12 inch round or square pans, plus a two-burner plate.

Weight changes how a pan feels in daily use. The comparison table shows the spread, from 2 pounds up to 9.38 pounds. If lifting a full pan is a concern, the Jean-Patrique Whatever Griddle Pan 10.6 Inch is a lighter alternative to cast iron, while the Lodge Reversible Cast Iron Grill/Griddle Pan is the biggest commitment.

Do ridges or a flat surface work better?

Ridges raise the steak above rendered fat and leave grill marks, which many buyers want for looks and flavor. A flat skillet makes full contact, which usually gives a more even crust and room for butter basting. Neither is wrong; it depends on whether you value the marks or the crust. If you lean flat, our page on the skillet for steak goes into that route in more detail.

What upkeep and oven use should you plan for?

Cast iron rewards a routine: wash gently, dry thoroughly and wipe a little oil on the surface to hold off rust. Nonstick pans clean easily but want gentler heat and tools. Thicker steaks often finish in the oven after searing, so check that the pan and handle can take it, and remember that some pan handles get very hot. When the oven does most of the cooking, the broiler pan for steaks is a purpose-built tool, and our page on it covers that approach.

Our picks at a glance

Frequently asked

Is cast iron or nonstick better for cooking steak?

Cast iron generally gives the deeper crust, because it stores heat and recovers quickly, and the Lodge Square Cast Iron Grill Pan 10.5 Inches is the pick for ridged searing. Nonstick is easier to clean and lighter, so the Sensarte Nonstick Grill Pan 9.5 Inch suits cooks who value convenience over maximum crust.

Can these grill pans be used on an induction cooktop?

Yes, for several. The Lodge Reversible Cast Iron Grill/Griddle Pan, Sensarte Nonstick Grill Pan 9.5 Inch and Carote Nonstick Grill Pan 11 Inch are all described as working on induction, and the Jean-Patrique Whatever Griddle Pan 10.6 Inch is reported to work well on induction by an owner.

How do you keep a cast iron pan from rusting?

Dry it right away after washing and rub on a thin layer of oil before storing. Owners of the cast iron pans here report rust, so the habit matters more than the brand, including with the Lodge 10.25 Inch Cast Iron Skillet and the Utopia Kitchen 12 Inch Cast Iron Skillet.